Archive for March, 2011

Published by Justin Lewis-Anthony on 24 Mar 2011

The Italian Crucifix Case and Judicial Wisdom

The “Italian Crucifix” case (LAUTSI AND OTHERS v. ITALY) has now been decided at the European Court of Human Rights Grand Chamber. I won’t comment on the merits of the case, or the merits of the judgement— others have done so, here, here and here— but rather I just want to do a disturbing fact about Judge Bonello’s concurring opinion.

In a wise and wide-ranging disquisition on the development of cultural norms, the difference between “secularism” and “freedom of religion”, and the meaning of “teaching” (as opposed to “indoctrination”), Judge Bonello concludes with “An Aside”. He mentions how the Court was once asked to judge on the pornographic intention and/or effect of Guillaume Apollinaire’s novel Les onze mille verges (the case was brought by the Turkish government). While recognizing that Apollinaire’s novel was pornographic, the Court defended its place within the European cultural tradition. Fair enough— but Judge Bonello’s authority was whether the novel was pornographic was WIKIPEDIA (which definition he helpfully footnotes!1)

Wikipedia determining cultural and moral judgements in the European Court! I suppose it is one step up above Justice Stewart’s authorities and references in the same question— but not much!2

  1. Footnote 3 “Wikipedia classifies this work as “a pornographic novel” in which the author “explores all aspects of sexuality: sadism alternates with masochism; ondinism/scatophilia with vampirism; paedophilia with genrontophilia; masturbation with group sex; lesbianism with homosexuality … the novel exudes an infernal joy”.” []
  2. Oh, and by the way, the link is ironically deliberate! []

Published by Justin Lewis-Anthony on 24 Mar 2011

Pentecost in Canterbury

How we celebrate Pentecost in St Stephen’s, Canterbury (!)
Red dye saturates Indian women at the Dauji Temple in Dauji, 113 miles south of New Delhi, on March 21. The Dauji Temple festivities are known for a ritual in which the women playfully hit men with whips made of cloth as men throw buckets of water with dye. (KevinFrayer/Associated Press) #

Suggestion from, and hat tip to, Scott Gunn

Published by Justin Lewis-Anthony on 23 Mar 2011

The Horror of Gonzo Christianity

I like this!

Tim LaHaye’s “Bible prophecy” scheme is full-gonzo insane. It’s based on an impossible and immoral reading of disparate scriptures cut-and-pasted into a not-quite coherent timeline of horror upon horror, a timeline that was invented in the 19th Century by fringe heretics and later embellished by profiteering Gantries preying on the gullible.

from here:

Published by Justin Lewis-Anthony on 23 Mar 2011

A claim on your generosity?

My son @jonasgla is fundraising for the Child Brain Injury Trust. He is attempting to get to Oslo, for free, dressed as a baby this coming Friday.

The CBIT is important to him and his friends, as their good friend, Tom Brenchley, died of brain injuries sustained in a motorbike accident last summer, shortly after completing the summer exams.

Today, Budget Day in the UK, and a week in which there are so many other claims on our time, money and attention, might not be the best day to stir the generosity of my readers. Even so, whatever you are able to do in supporting this worthy cause will help teenagers like Tom, who suffer traumatic injuries.

The easy way to give is via:

http://www.justgiving.com/Jonas-Lewis-Anthony

Thank you!

(BTW we’re hoping, if he raises enough money, he’ll stay in Oslo!)

Published by Justin Lewis-Anthony on 09 Mar 2011

Lent, an idea, and an action

John Petts's Window in the Sixteenth Street Baptist Church (h/t Eye Fetch)

On Sunday 15 September, 1963, just at the end of Sunday school and just as the main Sunday service was about to start, a bomb warning was telephoned in to the Sixteenth Street Baptist church of Birmingham, Alabama. The congregation were given less than three minutes warning. When the bomb exploded, four children were killed: Cynthia Wesley, Carole Robertson and Addie Mae Collins, all 14, and Denise McNair, aged 11. They had all been standing near a mirror, brushing their hair and adjusting their white dresses. Of course, all four girls, like the rest of the church congregation were black. The bombing had been perpetrated by a faction of the Ku Klux Klan in Alabama. It took fourteen years before the first of the bombers, Robert Chambliss, was arrested; 37 years before Thomas Blanton, was jailed, and Frank Cherry wasn’t convicted until 2002.

The atrocity was reported throughout the world, and, perhaps surprisingly, in the small Carmarthenshire village of Llansteffan, a man decided to do something about it. He was John Petts, an artist. Many years later he recalled: “Naturally, as a father, I was horrified by the death of the children. As a craftsman in a meticulous craft, I was horrified by the smashing of all those stained-glass windows. And I thought to myself, my word, what can we do about this?”

Petts’s idea was to set up a fund to replace the windows of the Sixteenth Street Baptist church, a fund to which the maximum contribution could be half a crown: “We don’t want some rich man as a gesture paying the whole window. We want it to be given by the people of Wales.”

The idea took on a life of its own, and money flowed in. There were pictures in the local and national press of children, black and white, queuing to hand their pocket money over. But what form should the window take? Petts puzzled about this:

Then it struck him. A verse from Matthew 25:40Open Link in New Window that spelt out the Christian message of brotherly love: “Truly, I say to you, as you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me.” Petts employed the last refrain: “You do it me”. Once the words were in place, the image followed. The window was installed in 1965. It showed a black figure, his chest thrust out and arms outstretched as though on a crucifix, the right one pushing away hatred and injustice, the left offering forgiveness. A rainbow, representing racial diversity, arcs over the head. Christ. As a black man. In the South. In the 60s.1

The most impressive thing about the whole story is Petts’s justification for what he did:
An idea doesn’t exist unless you do something about it. Thought has no real living meaning unless it’s followed by action of some kind.

There is a profound triviality about the way in which most Christians approach Lent: observing the holy season is limited to questions of “What I’m going to give up”, and discussions of what you couldn’t bear to live without— chocolate, beer, or Facebook. Every time this conversation takes place, the devil wins, because it is part of the devil’s always successful approach to human sinfulness and fallenness: make it a bit of a joke.

The Church has long recognized the way in which humanity’s fallen nature gets in the way of us taking our fallen nature seriously. This way the Church has developed practices, customs, disciplines, that allow us to do what is right without letting our selfish and lazy selves get in the way. Lent is the time in which the ascetism of the Christian life is most clearly expressed. To live an ascetic life, which is to say, to live a disciplined Christian life, means to take seriously the three-fold practices of almsgiving, prayer and fasting described in the Ash Wednesday Gospel (Matt 6:1-18Open Link in New Window). This three-fold practice covers all the bases, in a Christian ‘triangle’:

  • prayer means focussing on God
  • almsgiving means focussing on others;
  • only fasting focuses on yourself.

How can these three disciplines be the antidote to human fallenness? Let’s take them in reverse order:

  • Fasting means that we recognize our true needs, and don’t confuse “want” with “need”. It helps us to align ourselves away from thinking “Go on, you’re worth it”, and towards our commitments and relationships.
  • This outward commitment is continued in Almsgiving. This is not just “giving money to charity” (although that is good and necessary, for your and for the charities). Almsgiving is any practice of loving compassion and justice-making. It helps us to admit to our standing in the world and demonstrates what we truly value— not our possessions, reputation and achievement, but our involvement with others.
  • Prayer, which includes all the other “acts of the virtue of religion”— adoration, devotion, sacrifice, study and meditation— sustains our relationship with God and helps us understand fully what it means to say that it is in God we live and move and have our being (Acts 17:28Open Link in New Window).

In Lent we undertake these disciplines in the hope that the benefits they bring will take deeper root in our hearts and lives. It is important that we observe all three, for only then are we living within the reality identified by Jesus in the great commandment: you must love the Lord your God, and your neighbour as yourself.2

John Petts said:

An idea doesn’t exist unless you do something about it. Thought has no real living meaning unless it’s followed by action of some kind.

Lent doesn’t exist unless you do something about it.
Your Christian faith had no real living meaning unless it’s expressed by action of some kind.

To follow a holy Lent, a Lent in which the ascetic practices of the Church are taken seriously, gives you an opportunity to do this, to live as a disciple of Christ, and not as a hypocrite. God give us strength and grace to do so.

  1. from Gary Younge “American civil rights: the Welsh connection” www.guardian.co.uk p12 of the G2 section of the Guardian on Monday 7 March 2011 http://www.guardian.co.uk/artanddesign/2011/mar/06/racist-attack-alabama-1963-gary-younge []
  2. based on the wonderful injunction from the Godzdogz blog: http://godzdogz.op.org/ []

Published by Justin Lewis-Anthony on 07 Mar 2011

The Tea Party reaches Tripoli

Jeremy Bowen, the BBC correspondent in Tripoli, reported today on the nature of the pro-Gaddafi demonstrations in the capital:

In Green Square the evening’s pro-Gaddafi demonstrations were starting. They’re always noisy, but their numbers are not big for a city like Tripoli, which has a population of more than 2 million. Regular attendance at the demonstrations leaves you with the impression that only one slice of the population is represented. They are people who share the regime’s world-view— seeing the outside world as hostile, condemning the activities of foreign news networks, especially Arabic satellite channels, blaming foreigners allegedly wanting to steal Libya’s oil, and also blaming Al Qaeda for Libya’s troubles. The anti-Gaddaffi protests are now concentrated on Fridays, after the noon pray. They consider it too dangerous for them to assemble at any other time. The protesters tend to be better educated than the regime’s supporters, often speaking foreign languages, and with university degrees from the West. (Six O’Clock News, BBC Radio 4, 7 March 2011)

In what way does that not describe the demographic of the Tea Party? (even down to blaming Al Jazeera for Libya / America’s troubles!)